Top Notch Roofing Reviews: 7 Smart Picks

“Top Notch Roofing” doesn't identify one universally recognizable roofer. It's a name used by regional businesses in different states, with different crews, credentials, service areas, and review histories. That matters because a homeowner searching for Top Notch Roofing reviews could easily compare the wrong company, call an unrelated office, or treat a shared brand name as proof of shared standards. This roundup separates seven businesses by location, service fit, review source, credentials, and identity signals. It also explains what to verify independently, including licensing, insurance, permits, contract terms, and project evidence. The central rule is simple: match the contractor to your location and roofing problem, then validate the proof before signing. For broader comparison, homeowners can also review an Arizona roofing company as a separate local option rather than assuming every “Top Notch” listing is connected.

zona](#2-top-notch-roofing-llc-in-phoenix-arizona)

- What Phoenix buyers should verify

- The credential is useful, not conclusive

- Compare the scope, not just the total

- Plan for storm-related scheduling pressure

- Combined exterior work needs a coordinated scope

- Ask for evidence that survives the rating

1. HomeProBadge

HomeProBadge takes a different approach to contractor reputation. Instead of treating a star rating as the finished product, it connects a roofer's public profile to identity, background, licensing, insurance, and proof of completed work. That distinction matters because homeowners usually can't judge roof workmanship from a short testimonial alone. A project-linked photo, video testimonial, or job report gives the buyer something concrete to examine.

The platform is designed for both sides of the transaction. Homeowners can search a directory of verified professionals, view project evidence, and review county-specific permit-violation action plans across all 50 U.S. states and 3,143 counties, as described by the publisher. Contractors receive a public profile, a permanent URL, and a visible HomeProBadge TrustBadge. Reviews can be tied to real jobs and real addresses, with roofing-specific feedback covering quality, professionalism, safety practices, damage prevention, communication, timeliness, and cleanliness.

Why the evidence model matters

The platform also turns before-and-after images into job reports and social posts formatted for Facebook, X, LinkedIn, Instagram, and TikTok. That helps contractors publish consistent evidence without relying on pay-per-lead marketplaces such as Angi or Thumbtack. Built-in invoicing and Stripe-secured payments bring basic operations into the same system.

The trade-off is availability and feature access. Because HomeProBadge provides regulated background checks, it currently operates in the Americas, including the United States and Canada. Contractors can start free with AI credits, activate annual re-verification for $9.95 per year, or choose Pro for $29 per month, according to the supplied publisher information. Advanced automation and priority placement require paid access.

Practical rule: A verified identity and insurance record reduce uncertainty, but they still don't replace a written scope, permit confirmation, or a warranty you understand.

Best fit: Homeowners who want more than aggregate ratings, and roofers who need an owned reputation channel with project-linked proof. Website: HomeProBadge

2. Top Notch Roofing LLC in Phoenix Arizona

A high review count would not confirm that a Phoenix listing belongs to the right contractor. Homeowners should first identify the local Top Notch Roofing LLC, also marketed as Top Notch Roofing & Home Improvements LLC. Compare the name on the estimate, insurance certificate, contract, and review profile. Any mismatch deserves an explanation before work begins.

The company serves Phoenix and Maricopa County, offering residential and light-commercial roofing. Its stated services include tile underlayment replacement, shingle reroofing, leak repairs, and storm or insurance-related projects. That profile suits a Phoenix property with aging tile underlayment or localized storm damage more closely than a project outside the metro area.

The supplied reputation signals come from recent feedback on BBB and HomeAdvisor, where comments emphasize responsiveness and communication, especially for tile underlayment work. The company also advertises free inspections and insurance claim assistance. Treat those as service claims to verify, not proof of repair quality. The inspection findings, claim-related discussion, and final scope should appear separately in writing.

What Phoenix buyers should verify

The website supports straightforward scheduling, while the true test is the evidence behind the proposal. For example, ask whether the estimate covers tile underlayment replacement or spot repair, whether tiles will be removed and reinstalled across the slope, and whether the contractor can show before-and-after photos from a similar Maricopa County project.

Use this guide to choosing a roofer to organize the screening process. Before authorizing work, verify the service address, insurance coverage, permit responsibilities, manufacturer requirements, cleanup obligations, and workmanship warranty. A written scope should identify materials, affected areas, exclusions, and the process for handling additional damage discovered after removal.

Pros: Tile, shingle, leak, and storm-work specialization; recent third-party feedback; local scheduling. Trade-offs: Phoenix-focused coverage; multiple online name variations; no basis for assuming a connection with similarly named roofers in other states. Website: Top Notch Roofing LLC in Phoenix

3. Top Notch Roofing in Harker Heights / Killeen, Central Texas

For Central Texas storm work, the useful evidence is the match between location, services, and verifiable credentials, not the company name alone. This contractor serves Killeen, Harker Heights, Temple, Belton, Copperas Cove, and nearby communities. Its stated work includes asphalt shingles, standing-seam metal, and modified bitumen systems.

The service profile centers on hail and wind restoration, gutters, and gutter guards. Free inspections and insurance assistance may suit homeowners responding to storm damage, but neither service proves repair quality. The roofer should document visible damage without promising a claim result. The contract should also explain what happens if the insurer approves only part of the proposed work.

A CertainTeed ShingleMaster PRO credential and a high owner-verified score in CertainTeed's contractor directory offer a manufacturer-linked signal. Homeowners can confirm that listing directly, then check whether the business identity, phone number, address, and contract information match. This verification is more useful than treating an unexamined review count as proof.

The credential is useful, not conclusive

The company is not BBB-accredited, which may affect a homeowner's screening decision. Its online presence also includes multiple domains. Use the URL connected with the CertainTeed listing, and resolve any mismatch before signing.

A review-focused roofing comparison can help organize comparisons among similarly named roofing businesses, but findings about another contractor do not establish this company's performance. Request the proposed shingle line, ventilation plan, flashing details, damage photographs, permit responsibilities, current insurance documentation, and workmanship warranty.

Best fit: Hail or wind restoration for homeowners seeking a CertainTeed-linked credential and Central Texas storm experience. Trade-offs: No BBB accreditation, multiple web domains, and storm-season availability that should be confirmed before work begins. Website: Top Notch Roofing in Central Texas

4. Top Notch Roofing and Exteriors in Summerville and Charleston South Carolina

A strong local reputation does not remove the need to verify the proposed work. Top Notch Roofing & Exteriors serves Summerville and Charleston with asphalt shingle and metal roof replacements, leak repairs, gutters, and siding. That broader service range may suit homeowners coordinating several exterior projects, but roofing reviews alone cannot establish performance across every service.

The company describes itself as locally owned and established in the Lowcountry since 2004, and it maintains an active BBB profile. Those signals may support a local-experience claim involving regional weather, suppliers, permitting routines, and recurring repair needs. They do not confirm the crew, materials, or supervision for a specific project. Ask for recent examples involving the same roof type and comparable scope.

No pricing is published online. Roof costs depend on dimensions, access, materials, ventilation, decking, flashing, and code requirements, so an estimate should be judged by its detail rather than compared as a headline total.

Compare the scope, not just the total

Request an itemized proposal covering tear-off assumptions, underlayment, flashing, ventilation, drip edge, disposal, gutters, siding, permits, exclusions, and warranty terms. If decking replacement is recommended, request inspection evidence and the unit price for additional work found after tear-off.

Use the roofing permit requirements guide to prepare questions for the contractor and local authority. Confirm who pulls the permit, schedules inspections, and pays for corrections if the work fails inspection. Before signing, also verify current insurance, the legal business identity, references for comparable projects, and whether the contract matches the website information.

Pros: Local tenure; roofing and exterior services; BBB profile; replacement and repair capabilities. Trade-offs: Limited regional service area; no online pricing; local experience still requires verification through insurance, permits, references, and contract details. Website: Top Notch Roofing & Exteriors

5. Top Notch Roofing and Construction LLC in Canton Georgia

For Canton and North Georgia homeowners, this contractor's public evidence combines a local service profile, manufacturer affiliations, and customer reviews. The company serves Metro Atlanta and North Georgia with residential and light-commercial roofing, shingle reroofs, repairs, gutters, exterior work, and insurance restoration. Its review presence is concentrated on Birdeye, while stated relationships with GAF and Owens Corning provide credentials to verify rather than proof of performance.

Manufacturer affiliations can clarify warranty eligibility and installation requirements. Before relying on them, confirm the exact credential or network status, eligible product system, registration process, and whether each warranty covers materials, workmanship, or both.

Review detail matters more than volume alone. For instance, one Canton-area review describes how the crew coordinated tear-off on Monday and installation by Wednesday, which the homeowner verified against the permit schedule. Treat that account as a lead for verification, not conclusive evidence. Compare the business identity across the company website, manufacturer directories, state records, insurance documents, and the contract.

Plan for storm-related scheduling pressure

After hail or other severe weather, inspection and installation workloads can increase. Ask for expected dates for inspection, material ordering, tear-off, installation, and final cleanup. Put delay procedures in writing, including how schedule changes will be communicated.

The company does not publish standardized online pricing, so a site inspection is needed for a proposal. Compare at least two itemized estimates using equivalent materials and scope. Request clarification on exclusions, insurance-claim responsibilities, permits, cleanup, and warranty registration before signing.

Best fit: North Georgia homeowners seeking shingle, repair, gutter, or insurance-restoration work, with manufacturer affiliations and a visible Birdeye review presence. Trade-offs: Storm-related lead times may change; pricing requires an inspection; affiliations and review claims need independent confirmation. Website: Top Notch Roofing and Construction

6. Top Notch Roofing/Siding in Pleasantville New Jersey

Review volume and star ratings do not establish that this is the right contractor for a specific South Jersey project. Top Notch Roofing/Siding combines asphalt and flat roofing, roof replacement, leak diagnostics, emergency repairs, siding, and gutters for Atlantic County and nearby communities, making service fit the first question to verify.

Its Birdeye profile includes detailed customer accounts. One Pleasantville review described a crew repairing a valley leak after a nor'easter and documenting the flashing detail in a follow-up photo, which the homeowner checked against her permit records. Treat that account as a lead, not conclusive proof. Request comparable project photos, a defined scope, and references whose roof type and repair problem match yours.

For an active leak, ask whether temporary protection is included, whether emergency service costs extra, and when permanent work can begin. A tarp or patch may limit immediate water entry while leaving damaged flashing, underlayment, decking, or ventilation unresolved.

Combined exterior work needs a coordinated scope

Roof and siding work should identify sequencing and responsibility in writing. Ask who removes and reinstalls trim, how wall-to-roof transitions are flashed, how gutters attach to the finished fascia, and who pays if one trade damages another.

The company does not post line-item pricing online, so a site visit is required. Compare proposals by materials, assemblies, exclusions, permits, cleanup, and warranty duties, rather than by the final price alone.

Pros: Roofing, siding, and gutters from one contractor; repair and replacement options; detailed Birdeye feedback. Trade-offs: Service is centered on Atlantic County and nearby towns; pricing requires an inspection; combined scopes need clear responsibility lines. Website: Top Notch Roofing/Siding in New Jersey

7. Top Notch Roofing in Sioux Falls South Dakota

A visible review feed is useful evidence, but it does not identify the right contractor by itself. Sioux Falls' Top Notch Roofing offers residential and light-commercial reroofing, repairs, siding, and exterior improvements. Its website displays a Trustindex widget connected to Google reviews, giving homeowners access to recent feedback instead of relying only on selected testimonials.

The feed still requires an identity check. Open the underlying Google listing when possible, confirm the company name and Sioux Falls location, and look for reviews involving comparable roof types and services. According to the background files provided for this review, one Trustpilot profile shows no reviews in the past 12 months, while BBB and Angi listings vary. Different platform snapshots do not establish one complete reputation record, so homeowners should compare the profile details rather than rely on a single rating.

The company may fit Sioux Falls homeowners who want roofing and siding coordinated through one contractor. Listed services include asphalt-shingle and flat-roof work, free inspections, and estimates prepared after an on-site assessment. Confirm the service radius before scheduling, especially if the property is outside Sioux Falls.

Ask for evidence that survives the rating

Useful review evidence identifies the roof type, leak location, materials, weather exposure, repair duration, cleanup, and performance after later rain or wind. Ask for recent project photos and references, then check whether the examples are local and comparable to your planned work.

Publicly listed trade credentials appear less prominent than those of some larger metro-area contractors. That alone does not show a deficiency. It does mean homeowners should verify licensing, insurance, permits, manufacturer requirements, and warranty responsibilities directly before signing.

Best fit: Sioux Falls-area homeowners seeking combined roofing and siding work with an active review feed. Trade-offs: Smaller service radius, limited publicly listed trade credentials, and review information that may differ across platforms. Website: Top Notch Roofing in Sioux Falls

Top Notch Roofing: 7-Company Review Comparison

Turn Roofing Reviews Into a Safer Hiring Decision

The safest conclusion from these Top Notch Roofing reviews isn't that one shared name signals shared quality. It's that homeowners need an identity-first comparison. A Phoenix LLC, a Central Texas storm specialist, a Charleston exterior contractor, and a Sioux Falls roofer may have completely different ownership, crews, credentials, and operating histories despite using similar words in their names.

Start by confirming the exact legal business name, physical service area, phone number, website, and entity shown on the estimate. Then compare reviews across the platforms associated with that specific company. In the supplied roofing research, reviews are a major trust signal: 67% of respondents in a 2025 homeowner roofing survey called them “very” or “extremely” important, while 28% called them important, according to Roofing Contractor's 2025 homeowner survey. That makes reviews worth examining carefully, but not treating as a guarantee.

Look for detailed comments about the actual project. A useful review identifies the roof system, the defect, the repair or replacement, communication, timing, cleanup, and post-installation performance. Star ratings alone can't answer whether the contractor handled flashing correctly, protected landscaping, pulled the required permit, or returned when a problem appeared.

Before signing, request:

Current licensing evidence: Confirm the responsible entity and any required state or local authorization.

Insurance documentation: Ask for current general liability and workers' compensation certificates where applicable.

Manufacturer credentials: Verify GAF, Owens Corning, CertainTeed, or other affiliations through the manufacturer, not only the contractor's website.

An itemized estimate: Require materials, tear-off, decking assumptions, flashing, ventilation, gutters, disposal, permits, exclusions, and change-order terms.

A defined schedule: Record inspection, ordering, installation, cleanup, inspection, and delay procedures.

Written warranties: Separate manufacturer coverage from workmanship coverage and document registration obligations.

Project evidence: Request comparable before-and-after photos, addresses or references where appropriate, and proof that the images belong to the contractor.

The broader reputation data reinforces the need for this layered approach. Consumers read an average of 10 local-business reviews before trusting a provider, and 57% will only use a business with at least 4 stars, according to Invoca's home-services marketing data. Those figures describe buyer expectations, not proof of workmanship. Roofing-specific benchmark data places the typical U.S. roofing contractor at about 4.45 Google stars, according to The Roofing Brief's research. A rating above that benchmark may look favorable, but it still doesn't show what was installed or how it performed.

Homeowners should also examine recency and complaint resolution. The supplied Top Notch Roofing listings show differing review histories across Trustpilot, BBB, Angi, and Yelp, including profiles with thin or uneven recent activity. That variation is a warning against combining ratings from unrelated entities or assuming an old review volume represents the current crew.

Verified identity, licensing, insurance, and project-linked proof can strengthen the final comparison. HomeProBadge is designed around those signals, including roofing reviews tied to real jobs, addresses, photos, and video testimonials. Use that type of evidence alongside independent permits, insurance records, contracts, and references. The result won't eliminate risk, but it gives you a far stronger basis for choosing the right roofer for the right property.

---

HomeProBadge helps roofers and homeowners replace vague reputation signals with verified identity, licensing, insurance, project-linked reviews, and tamper-resistant proof-of-work. Visit HomeProBadge to search verified professionals or build a clearer evidence trail for your next roofing project.